The art of hitting a target you cannot see
A Beyond Visual Range (BVR) Missile is a clever piece of engineering. It is designed to hit a target that its master cannot see with the naked eye. The missile is launched on the basis of available information, calculations, and a fair amount of faith in technology. By the time it reaches the target, the target may have changed its position, speed or direction. The missile has to deal with all these uncertainties and still find its quarry.
I have often wondered whether there is a lesson here for management. In fact, I suspect that some of our best managers are nothing but BVR missiles in human form.
THE MANAGER WHO LOOKS BEYOND THE OBVIOUS
A manager of ordinary prudence would like all the facts on the table, all the variables identified, all the risks quantified and, if possible, a written assurance from the universe that nothing will go wrong. Unfortunately, the universe is not particularly cooperative. Neither is the competition.
The customer may change his mind. The supplier may fail to deliver. The government changes a policy. A competitor launches a product nobody had anticipated. A promising technology turns out to be a dead end. This is where the BVR Manager comes into his own. He looks beyond what is immediately visible. He attempts to read the direction in which events are moving, anticipates possibilities, and takes decisions without waiting for the comforting luxury of complete information.
The BVR manager takes his shot. Not recklessly, not necessarily impulsively, but with an appreciation of the fact that uncertainty is not an unfortunate exception to business. It is an integral part of it.
THE MYSTERIOUS SIXTH SENSE
Some managers seem to possess an uncanny ability to make the right calls. They sense a market opportunity before it becomes obvious to others. They recognise a promising employee whom the appraisal system has failed to notice. They abandon a project that looks perfectly healthy on paper but feels wrong to them. Or they back an idea that everyone else considers premature, only to see it become the next big thing.
What do we call this ability? A hunch? Intuition? A sixth sense? Or simply good luck?
The difficulty is that when such a manager succeeds, everybody is impressed. When he succeeds repeatedly, people begin to wonder whether he possesses some mysterious faculty unavailable to the rest of humanity. He listens to people, asks a few apparently innocuous questions, and then announces a decision that leaves everyone wondering whether they have missed an important chapter of the management textbook.
Sometimes, of course, he is wrong. No missile hits its target every time, and no manager has an unblemished record. But what distinguishes the good BVR Manager is the consistency of his results over time.
WHERE DOES THIS ABILITY COME FROM?
His successes are not necessarily the result of any supernatural insight. What appears to be intuition may actually be the subconscious processing of thousands of observations, experiences and patterns accumulated over the years. A seasoned manager may not be able to explain precisely why a particular proposal makes him uncomfortable. He may simply say, “Something doesn't add up.” Experience, it appears, has a way of converting information into instinct.
Is the BVR Manager born with this ability, or does he acquire it? Is it a product of experience, an innate appetite for the unknown, or simply a stronger stomach for risk? Perhaps it is a combination of all three.
Experience teaches us patterns. Repeated exposure to complex situations helps us recognise connections between apparently unrelated events. A manufacturing manager who has handled hundreds of production crises may recognise the early symptoms of a serious breakdown long before the monitoring system raises an alarm. A railway operations manager may sense that a seemingly minor disruption is about to cascade into a major operational problem.
Neither may be able to articulate the entire chain of reasoning. But their brains have been quietly doing the calculations. Then there is the appetite for uncertainty.
We certainly need meticulous people to ensure that trains run safely or airlines operate flawlessly, products meet specifications and financial transactions are properly accounted for. A BVR approach is not a licence to disregard rules, safety requirements or technical evidence. But leadership often demands something more. It demands the ability to act when the evidence is insufficient, the clock is ticking and the cost of inaction may be greater than the cost of a carefully considered mistake.
And finally, there is risk appetite.
The BVR Manager accepts that a decision may fail. He does not confuse the possibility of failure with proof that a decision should not be taken. He understands that a zero-risk strategy may be the surest way of achieving zero progress.
CAN BUSINESS SCHOOLS TEACH THE ART?
This brings us to a question that should interest every business school. Can we teach people to become BVR Managers?
Business schools are reasonably good at teaching the visible parts of management. They teach financial analysis, operations research, marketing, accounting, strategy and organisational behaviour. Students learn to construct models, evaluate alternatives and prepare business plans. They are taught to identify risks, calculate probabilities and optimise outcomes. All very useful.
But the real world has a nasty habit of refusing to behave like a case study. What does the textbook recommend when the information is incomplete, the assumptions are unreliable and the consequences of waiting are potentially disastrous? There may be a chapter on decision-making under uncertainty. But reading about uncertainty and actually having to make a decision under it are two entirely different experiences.
Can a business school teach a student to recognise a market that does not yet exist? Can it teach him to distinguish a genuine opportunity from an attractive delusion? Can it teach him when to trust his intuition and when to distrust it?
Perhaps not directly. But that does not mean it cannot prepare him.
THE CORPORATE TRAINING GAP
Corporations, too, have a role to play. Most organisations have elaborate systems for monitoring performance, evaluating employees and measuring compliance. They conduct training programmes, leadership workshops and strategic planning exercises. Yet they frequently reward managers for meeting predictable targets while penalising them for experiments that fail. The result is a curious contradiction. We ask managers to innovate, but we expect them to produce a business case that guarantees success before we permit them to begin.
We encourage initiative and innovation, provided it does not disturb established procedures. We ask people to think out of the box, but the moment they step outside it, somebody from some compliance department appears with a measuring tape.
In such an environment, the safest career strategy is obvious: avoid decisions that can go wrong, seek approval from several levels above, and ensure that every eventuality has been recorded in writing.
Perhaps business schools should introduce a compulsory course called Management Beyond Visual Range. The title may sound like an elective for fighter pilots, but the subject is central to leadership. The course would not teach students to become gamblers. It would teach them to recognise situations in which waiting for certainty is itself a decision, often a costly one.
It would help them understand the difference between information and insight, between confidence and competence, between calculated risk and reckless speculation. And it would remind them that intuition is not an excuse for avoiding analysis. The best judgement combines evidence, experience, imagination and a willingness to question one's own conclusions.
THE FINAL APPROACH
Perhaps the greatest challenge is that the ability to manage beyond visual range is difficult to measure. We can count how many courses a manager has attended, how many certificates he has collected and how many presentations he has delivered. We can even measure his quarterly performance. But how do we measure his ability to recognise an opportunity before others see it? How do we evaluate the quality of a decision whose outcome will become apparent only five years later?
And how do we distinguish a genuinely perceptive manager from a lucky one who happens to be standing in the right place at the right time? These are difficult questions, but they are not reasons to abandon the pursuit.
A good manager must therefore learn to look beyond what is immediately visible, make sense of what little he knows, and act with a clear understanding of what he does not know. He may not always hit the target. But if he waits until he can see it with absolute clarity, he may find that somebody else has already got there.
And that, perhaps, is the real lesson of Beyond Visual Range Management.
—-ooo—-

