Monday, 16 November 2026

BEYOND VISUAL RANGE MANAGEMENT

 The art of hitting a target you cannot see


A Beyond Visual Range (BVR) Missile is a clever piece of engineering. It is designed to hit a target that its master cannot see with the naked eye. The missile is launched on the basis of available information, calculations, and a fair amount of faith in technology. By the time it reaches the target, the target may have changed its position, speed or direction. The missile has to deal with all these uncertainties and still find its quarry.


I have often wondered whether there is a lesson here for management. In fact, I suspect that some of our best managers are nothing but BVR missiles in human form.


THE MANAGER WHO LOOKS BEYOND THE OBVIOUS


A manager of ordinary prudence would like all the facts on the table, all the variables identified, all the risks quantified and, if possible, a written assurance from the universe that nothing will go wrong. Unfortunately, the universe is not particularly cooperative. Neither is the competition.


The customer may change his mind. The supplier may fail to deliver. The government changes a policy. A competitor launches a product nobody had anticipated. A promising technology turns out to be a dead end. This is where the BVR Manager comes into his own. He looks beyond what is immediately visible. He attempts to read the direction in which events are moving, anticipates possibilities, and takes decisions without waiting for the comforting luxury of complete information.


The BVR manager takes his shot. Not recklessly, not necessarily impulsively, but with an appreciation of the fact that uncertainty is not an unfortunate exception to business. It is an integral part of it.


THE MYSTERIOUS SIXTH SENSE


Some managers seem to possess an uncanny ability to make the right calls. They sense a market opportunity before it becomes obvious to others. They recognise a promising employee whom the appraisal system has failed to notice. They abandon a project that looks perfectly healthy on paper but feels wrong to them. Or they back an idea that everyone else considers premature, only to see it become the next big thing.


What do we call this ability? A hunch? Intuition? A sixth sense? Or simply good luck?


The difficulty is that when such a manager succeeds, everybody is impressed. When he succeeds repeatedly, people begin to wonder whether he possesses some mysterious faculty unavailable to the rest of humanity. He listens to people, asks a few apparently innocuous questions, and then announces a decision that leaves everyone wondering whether they have missed an important chapter of the management textbook.


Sometimes, of course, he is wrong. No missile hits its target every time, and no manager has an unblemished record. But what distinguishes the good BVR Manager is the consistency of his results over time.


WHERE DOES THIS ABILITY COME FROM?


His successes are not necessarily the result of any supernatural insight. What appears to be intuition may actually be the subconscious processing of thousands of observations, experiences and patterns accumulated over the years. A seasoned manager may not be able to explain precisely why a particular proposal makes him uncomfortable. He may simply say, “Something doesn't add up.” Experience, it appears, has a way of converting information into instinct.


Is the BVR Manager born with this ability, or does he acquire it? Is it a product of experience, an innate appetite for the unknown, or simply a stronger stomach for risk? Perhaps it is a combination of all three.


Experience teaches us patterns. Repeated exposure to complex situations helps us recognise connections between apparently unrelated events. A manufacturing manager who has handled hundreds of production crises may recognise the early symptoms of a serious breakdown long before the monitoring system raises an alarm. A railway operations manager may sense that a seemingly minor disruption is about to cascade into a major operational problem.


Neither may be able to articulate the entire chain of reasoning. But their brains have been quietly doing the calculations. Then there is the appetite for uncertainty.


We certainly need meticulous people to ensure that trains run safely or airlines operate flawlessly, products meet specifications and financial transactions are properly accounted for. A BVR approach is not a licence to disregard rules, safety requirements or technical evidence. But leadership often demands something more. It demands the ability to act when the evidence is insufficient, the clock is ticking and the cost of inaction may be greater than the cost of a carefully considered mistake.

And finally, there is risk appetite.


The BVR Manager accepts that a decision may fail. He does not confuse the possibility of failure with proof that a decision should not be taken. He understands that a zero-risk strategy may be the surest way of achieving zero progress.


CAN BUSINESS SCHOOLS TEACH THE ART?


This brings us to a question that should interest every business school. Can we teach people to become BVR Managers?

Business schools are reasonably good at teaching the visible parts of management. They teach financial analysis, operations research, marketing, accounting, strategy and organisational behaviour. Students learn to construct models, evaluate alternatives and prepare business plans. They are taught to identify risks, calculate probabilities and optimise outcomes. All very useful.


But the real world has a nasty habit of refusing to behave like a case study. What does the textbook recommend when the information is incomplete, the assumptions are unreliable and the consequences of waiting are potentially disastrous? There may be a chapter on decision-making under uncertainty. But reading about uncertainty and actually having to make a decision under it are two entirely different experiences.


Can a business school teach a student to recognise a market that does not yet exist? Can it teach him to distinguish a genuine opportunity from an attractive delusion? Can it teach him when to trust his intuition and when to distrust it?

Perhaps not directly. But that does not mean it cannot prepare him.


THE CORPORATE TRAINING GAP


Corporations, too, have a role to play. Most organisations have elaborate systems for monitoring performance, evaluating employees and measuring compliance. They conduct training programmes, leadership workshops and strategic planning exercises. Yet they frequently reward managers for meeting predictable targets while penalising them for experiments that fail. The result is a curious contradiction. We ask managers to innovate, but we expect them to produce a business case that guarantees success before we permit them to begin.


We encourage initiative and innovation, provided it does not disturb established procedures. We ask people to think out of the box, but the moment they step outside it, somebody from some compliance department appears with a measuring tape.


In such an environment, the safest career strategy is obvious: avoid decisions that can go wrong, seek approval from several levels above, and ensure that every eventuality has been recorded in writing.


Perhaps business schools should introduce a compulsory course called Management Beyond Visual Range. The title may sound like an elective for fighter pilots, but the subject is central to leadership. The course would not teach students to become gamblers. It would teach them to recognise situations in which waiting for certainty is itself a decision, often a costly one.


It would help them understand the difference between information and insight, between confidence and competence, between calculated risk and reckless speculation. And it would remind them that intuition is not an excuse for avoiding analysis. The best judgement combines evidence, experience, imagination and a willingness to question one's own conclusions.


THE FINAL APPROACH


Perhaps the greatest challenge is that the ability to manage beyond visual range is difficult to measure. We can count how many courses a manager has attended, how many certificates he has collected and how many presentations he has delivered. We can even measure his quarterly performance. But how do we measure his ability to recognise an opportunity before others see it? How do we evaluate the quality of a decision whose outcome will become apparent only five years later?


And how do we distinguish a genuinely perceptive manager from a lucky one who happens to be standing in the right place at the right time? These are difficult questions, but they are not reasons to abandon the pursuit.


A good manager must therefore learn to look beyond what is immediately visible, make sense of what little he knows, and act with a clear understanding of what he does not know. He may not always hit the target. But if he waits until he can see it with absolute clarity, he may find that somebody else has already got there.


And that, perhaps, is the real lesson of Beyond Visual Range Management.

—-ooo—-

Sunday, 5 July 2026

The E20 Conundrum - A Technical Critique

 



A question boggling our minds in recent times is whether the E20 Petrol is harmful to our car and scooter engines. Whereas the mainstream media is surprisingly quiet and is merely repeating the press-briefings of the government or proceedings of some hurriedly called conferences of experts, it is the social media that is critical of a forced migration of nearly twenty-five crore engines to the 20% Ethanol-blend universally dispensed at petrol pumps. I felt there was a need to present a purely technical critique of the E20 movement, free from political rhetoric and perceived gains or losses. Here it is.

What is the immediate impact of E20 on us in entirety, not limited to our petrol vehicles.

1.  Lower Power from our engines:

Ethanol has far lower calorific value than pure petrol. That is because of the chemistry and can’t be dismissed by arguments.

Combustion energy of both fuels and the impact on E20 is given below:

Petrol                 43.0 MJ/Kg

Ethanol              26.8 MJ/Kg

E20                     39.6 MJ/Kg

Net Loss             7.9%

It is clear that there is a reduction of 7.9% in the combustion heat in the cylinders. A recent public statement of Anurag Saraogi, the ED of Biofuels Division of BPCL confirms that there is significant drop in mileage with Ethanol. Fortunately, modern car engines can partially compensate it with some automatic tweaking, such as injection timing, mixture control etc. but only to the extent of 2-3%. So, ideally speaking cars will suffer a loss of power of about 5-6%, though a controlled trial can establish the real figure. The same can’t be said of motorcycles, which are build with much less sophistication. And motorcycles and scooters are the mainstay of the masses. Users, of cars and scooters both, have reported upto 15% loss in mileage. That means that one has to use 15% extra fuel for travelling the same distance. That is a minimum 15% hit to your wallet. Besides, if one uses 15% extra of E20, of which 12% (80% of the mix) would be petrol, the saving on fossil fuel would be marginal at best.

2.  Impact on Rubber and Plastic Parts:

Ethanol is an organic solvent and attacks rubber gaskets, seals, and pipelines. This early decay of rubber parts may lead to leakages of fuel, lubricants, air and compressed gases from the cylinders. Replacing them with suitable plastics or alloys will overcome this problem even in older cars, but at significant cost and downtime. The problem with this decay is that once it sets in it will accelerate quickly.

3.  Corrosion of Metal Parts of the Engine:

Ethanol is soluble in, or dissolves in itself, both petrol and water. The hydroxyl group end of the Ethanol molecule mixes well with water and the ethyl group at the other end with petrol. While ethanol dissolves perfectly into petrol, introducing water changes the equation entirely. If an ethanol-petrol blend absorbs too much water, the ethanol's chemical affinity for the water will overpower its bond with the petrol.

There is a miniscule amount of water (permitted by law) even in pure petrol. That water is not miscible with petrol and settles down in the fuel tank. This water accumulates over time and is a cause of corrosion in the sheet metal of the fuel tank. But this corrosion was largely limited to the tank. If you run your car till the tank is nearly empty, some water from the bottom would be sucked by the fuel pump and circulated all around. Scooter and Motorcycle engines draw their fuel by gravity from the bottom of the fuel tank, which means that they are always drawing some water. They also run until their tanks are near empty (a matter of habit) further aggravating the problem.

Ethanol and water make a good solution. It is then circulated all around the engine. Some water would then settle down in the engine sump, where the lube oil lives, over time. This water in circulation causes severe corrosion of engine parts – liners, pistons, connecting-rods, crankshaft and camshaft, rocker arms and pins, gears and many more. This corrosion is devastating and will demand costly repairs.

Besides Ethanol itself is hygroscopic, meaning it naturally attracts and absorbs moisture from the surrounding environment. Because water and petrol do not mix, the heavier water-ethanol mixture will drop out of the petrol suspension and sink to the bottom of the fuel tank. This phase separation can severely damage an engine if the fuel pump draws from the watery layer at the bottom of the tank.

Solution

While the government has not yet conclusively clarified that controlled trials were conducted on petrol engines of cars and scooters, it is not relenting on E20 and pushing ahead with plans for higher blends. There is some loose talk of E20 compliant vehicles. Let’s examine the technical options.

a)  E20 Compliant Engines – Official claims of there being no damage to engines is amply countered by users in the social media. Engines are opened up and blackened engine parts, rubber components, sludge in the engine are shown as proofs of the extensive damage that E20 has done to their vehicles. Such extensive damage is not possible in a few months, or even a year or two, of usage and, in my opinion, many of those are simply result of poor maintenance. Loss of mileage, on the other hand, is a fact established by Chemistry and Thermodynamics.

Government’s claims that there is no damage to the engine yet asking that vehicles become E20 compliant are contradictory. Both can’t be true.

The quick route to E20 compliance is change of rubber and plastic parts to ethanol resistant designs. This would mean replacing all seals, gaskets, fuel-pipelines at significant cost. Repair and/or replacement will also be needed to fuel-pump, the fuel tank will need to be coated with polymer or special paints. There will, therefore, be many days of vehicle downtime.

b)  Engine Optimised for E20 – In the long run an IC engine can be optimised to not only overcome these problems but also exploit the benefits of Ethanol. Some of the modifications would be as under. They are so large and costly that only new vehicles will have them. Only a few are discussed here.

 (i)  ECU calibration

There will be need of a software upgrade since Ethanol burns differently. Modification will be required in:

    ·       Injection duration

    ·       Ignition timing

    ·       Cold-start enrichment

    ·        Knock detection

(ii)   Compression ratio (Optimization) – Engine Geometry

This is where the real gains will happen as offered by Ethanol.

Petrol engines typically have compression ratio of 10:1. This can easily go up to 12:1 or even 13:1 since Ethanol offers high Octane number chemically. This change in engine design alone will not only offset the loss in mileage felt at present but take the fuel efficiency near that of diesel engines.

(iii) Changes/Improvements in Materials – The problem of water in the fuel and resultant corrosion, sludge in the lubricating oil etc. can only be solved by better materials. Ethanol is hygroscopic as well as a good solvent and needs to be addressed with such changes, if smooth and fault-free engine operations is needed for years. Apart from the changes needed in an E20 compliant engine, following will be needed among others: 

    ·       Stainless steel or coated fuel lines

    ·       Ethanol-compatible fuel pump

    ·       Compatible injector materials

    ·       Modified fuel tank coatings

(iv) Ignition Timing – Ignition timing, along with changes in engine geometry, can be a game changer since Ethanol tolerates more spark advance before knocking. Whereas a compatible engine advances timing only slightly, an E20 optimized engine can take it to the mechanical limits of the engine. This extracts more pressure, and hence work, during the power stroke.

(v)  Combustion Chamber Redesign - An E20 optimized engine, as opposed to an E20 compliant one will also require modifications to the Piston crown shape, Squish areas, Swirl and tumble, Injector spray pattern, Valve timing etc.

Why Ethanol is the Future?

Ethanol blend, if done well, not only saves fossil fuels and foreign exchange, it also actually improves the performance of the engine. It permits a higher compression ratio due to its high Octane number. A higher compression ratio improves the thermodynamic efficiency of the Otto Cycle.

Ethanol has a higher latent heat of evaporation. The charge-air is therefore cooler and more of it, in weight, can be admitted into the combustion chamber thus improving not only combustion efficiency but also the power since more fuel can now be burnt.

The turbo charger can be redesigned to create higher charge air pressure for the new engine.

Are We Ready for an Ethanol Future

It is clear from the above that optimised E20 engines will need huge investments in Research and Design, changes in production processes, new supply chains, new approvals etc. An E20 compliant vehicle will be totally new beast and may even cost much higher than the existing models.

Are we ready for it? Maybe, we are. But if the goal posts keep moving to E30, E40 and E100, the technology remains in a flux, and the Indian car and scooter owner is doomed.

---ooo---

 

Tuesday, 14 October 2025

How to Break Rules (Or Bend Them), Part 1

There have been many social media posts, bordering on righteous indignation, about how a rule was upheld and the powerful were shown their place. However, do not, for a moment, forget the warriors in the government, who are required to deliver in spite of the rigour of government rules applied to a business organisation.


Well, here is an example of how a rule was broken (or bent) to earn money for the Railways, for isn’t that what we are supposed to do primarily. A cement company in my Division (Salem) had its lorry operators go on strike. Their shipments to Kerala were held up and inventory was piling up. Seeking business opportunity, I sent my brilliant SrDOM to visit them. They were thrilled to host the SrDOM, who asked them how Railways could help them. They said that they wanted a half-rake (or a mini rake of BCNs, i.e. 21 covered wagons) every day. The SrDOM checked with me on phone. Not knowing my limitations I advised the SrDOM to promise them a half-rake everyday provided they loaded on Sundays too.


Next day in office I found out that an empty rake was available and then told the SrDOM to send half of it, as a mini rake, to the cement company. He said, “But Sir, the CFTM from Head Quarters wants the empty rake to be sent to SCRly.” I asked him if it was wise to send an empty rake nearly four hundred kilometers away, when business awaited at mere fifteen. He expressed helplessness and I understood. The glorified post of DRM has very little say in the commercial business of IR, though he/she is held accountable if there is a drop. Every single rake placement is decided by the operating department from HQ under central directives of the TT directorate of the Board, generally bypassing the DRMs and GMs.


I then called the SrDME and told him to “mark half the rake sick (defective)”, which was promptly done. Then I told the SrDOM that half the rake was unfit anyway and to place the “fit half” in the cement company’s siding. It was done. The next day, the SrDME was asked to “make the other half fit”, which too was done and the rake placed promptly. Thus the firm loaded the second mini-rake. Now, one could say that this was a clear case of “favour” to a private party and could invite a vigilance enquiry. However, I know no other rule than one that favours the customer.


The CFTM understood that I meant business and backed off, though not completely. When the hundredth rake was loaded, he was prompt in writing a letter to the Railway Board claiming credit for the feat. The bigger bada sahib, the PCOM, paid a visit to the cement company to receive profuse thanks and enjoyed a dinner hosted by them. The DRM was not taken along :-)


That year the Division had a 478% increase in cement loading, nearly six times business compared to the previous year. There was a general drop of 6% in cement loading across the rest of Indian Railways. This was achieved even when our tariff was 35% higher than that charged by road transporters. The cement company terminated the road transport contract.


The CFTM later became a DRM and called me for tips. I told him that the first thing he should do was to ignore his CFTM.

                           —-ooo—-

Tuesday, 5 August 2025

Of Rexine and Railways


When we were building the prototype Train-18 in ICF, we were insisting on and buying the best-in-class material. A delegation of Rexine and PVC Flooring manufacturers visited me. They were protesting that we were buying German products and not encouraging Indian industry. The seat upholstery – rexine, fabric and rubber flooring – made in Germany, were available in India against Rupee payment. So, we were absolved of the moral guilt of importing. These are special fire-retardant materials conforming to EN-45545 HL3, a German standard for fire resistance and flame, smoke and toxin free burning even when they combusted. This standard is followed the world over as an essential safety measure.

The delegation that came to see me complained that we had never asked or demanded from them the need to develop interiors to the EN standard. They also promised to match the best German supplies if challenged, and at lower prices. The train construction was well underway and we had already ordered the fabric, rexine and flooring for the prototypes. So, I promised to involve them in future purchases. After all we were making only the first two trains as prototypes.

Well, after listening to them it was my turn to question them on the poor quality they had been supplying. I told them that even the current supplies that they were making, of rexine etc. was so inexcusably poor and that I found it difficult to repose much faith in their promises. What they told me was an eye opener. 

One of them brought out two samples of rexine upholstery material. One sample had a good and dense fabric backing with a thick and robust layer of blue PVC coated on it. The other one was a feeble fabric with the thinnest PVC coating. He said, “Sir, you in the Railways insist on buying poor quality at the lowest prices. What can we do? We must cut corners to make even the smallest profit.” This second, poor piece, is a sample of what we supply to the Railways for forty to fifty rupees a square meter. The better one is what we supply to several State Transport Corporations for the seats of their buses; the price they pay is a hundred seventy-five rupees per square metre, four times your price.

And, then he dropped the bombshell, “Sir, do you know what specification the STCs follow? They follow RDSO specifications. He showed me the Purchase Orders from two State Transport Corporations as proof of their effective purchase systems. You can see the UPSRTC purchase order in the picture above.

This, sadly, is the state of our purchase system in the Railways where all departments must be held guilty.  The Stores Department that insists on expanding the vendor list in some pseudo democratisation of equal opportunity to every Tom, Dick, and Harry. The Finance that with its insistence on price, and price alone, doesn’t care about the quality. But the biggest culprit is the technical department, which meekly surrenders to the other two and doesn’t enforce its responsibility and rights to get the best value for money - durable, safe, and low-maintenance material.

The compulsion to play it safe makes us accept poor quality even when we are consciously aware of our technical guilt. Repeated tenders with fly-by-night-operators, masquerading as OEMs, drive down the prices to unsustainable levels. The failure of the purchase system is all pervasive; rexine was just an example. The ultimate result is an unforgivable quality, low reliability, pathetic levels of customer satisfaction, and repeated purchase of the same poor stuff, again and again.

                                                              ---ooo---

 

Wednesday, 26 March 2025

Reindustrialisation - A Generational Project


Loss of manufacturing in a country is not only shutting down of factories. Its repercussions are far deeper and wider. Factories are run over by nature, machines and assembly lines jam up, corrode, rust and crumble and can never be revived. Industrial towns are abandoned; one only has to look at the fate that befell once celebrated industrial cities of USA – Detroit, St. Louis, Pittsburgh, Cleveland and many more, where populations have declined to half or a third of their peak. People move out to seek other avenues of earning. Shops and restaurants, schools and colleges, town halls and parks, hospitals and offices, car dealerships and cab companies, all shut down. The loss of jobs is several times larger than just those of shop floor workers. All this is only because some unknown city across the ocean can sell cars and steel, televisions and toys a few percent cheaper.

What is worse is that the very backbone of the affected industry is broken. Skilled workers, who could make the finest cars and implements, toys and gadgets scatter, never to come back together under one roof to recreate the magic. The entire supply-chains, which typically come from the Medium and Small Industries (MSMEs), dry up since the bulk buyer has downed its shutters. MSMEs are the major job creators in any country and economy. Shutting down of these smaller units is devastating though not as spectacular as that of a car company. The latter’s loss of business is a subject of headlines and debates but not of the feeder small industries even though the impact on jobs and livelihood of workers of these MSMEs is far bigger. Entire capital is wiped out and bankruptcies are more common among MSMEs. Their employees often have lower levels of social security and entire families are driven to penury.

What Happens When a Car Factory Shuts Down?

Let’s take the example of a large car factory with US$10 billion in sales and the cascade of job losses and misery that follows when it shuts down. Such a car plant would typically be manufacturing 5,00,000 cars per annum.

The factory sources its parts and sub-assemblies as follows (only material cost taken here):

    In-house production:              10-15%

    Tier 1 (large) Suppliers:          50-60%

    Tier 2&3 (MSME) Suppliers:  25-30%      

When the factory shuts down:

  • Main Plant: 7500 direct employees of the company are laid off
  • Tier 1: 30,000 workers are laid off (These suppliers typically employ 3-5 workers per every worker in the main plant). Tier 1 companies typically manufacture engines, transmissions, brake systems, and electronics.
  • Tier 2: 75,000 workers lose their jobs. (Tier 2 suppliers typically employ 2-3 workers for every one worker in Tier 1). They manufacture sub-components such as wiring, seats, rubber-parts, and smaller assemblies.
  • Tier 3: 1,12,500 employees are rendered jobless. (Tier 3 suppliers typically employ 1-1.5 workers for every one worker in Tier 2). They typically produce basic components, such as metals, plastics, rubber and small parts.
  • Indirect Job Losses: 5,60,000 work hands lose their livelihood. As a multiplier effect for every manufacturing job lost 2-3 additional jobs are lost. They are typically in activities such as logistics, sales, dealerships, maintenance, catering, janitorial, services, security, transportation, schools, city-workers and all other local businesses that rely on factories and factory workers as customers.

Let’s summarise these job losses:

    Total manufacturing jobs:   2,25,000

    Indirect jobs:                        5,60,000

    Total Estimated Layoffs:     7,85,000

A disclaimer: Not all job-losses will be in the same country, state, or neighborhood. The ripples of a major factory shutting down will be felt across the world given the way supply-chains are established. One should look at ghost cities of China as a result of supply-chain dislocation let alone major factories closing down.    

Knee Jerk Reaction

Loss of factories, large and small, their equipment, skilled manpower, market-lines of their products, the service and after-sales business, all happen slowly, over years, decades or sometimes over the span of an entire generation.

Governments, policymakers, captains of industry and occasionally the affected population suddenly wake up one day and begin to talk in fuzzy terms like reshoring, onshoring, tariffs, China+1 etc. Little do they realise that in a deindustrialised country, bringing back factories must take the same long route in reverse. You can’t simply bring back blast furnaces and rolling mills to Pittsburgh, or cotton mills to Mumbai. Re-industrialisation is a generational project, not to be achieved in a few years of a government’s rule span. Remember these industrial centres were built by the blood and sweat of generations of entrepreneurs and workers.

What Needs to be Done?

Some of the unavoidable and quick action plans may include:

  • Policy changes that facilitate easy creation of industrial units, large and small
  • Easing of regulatory control
  • Easy access to banking and capital
  • Infrastructure Development – Highways, ports, power plants and power grids
  • Easy availability of land and permits
  • Low energy cost
  • Healthcare and social security
  • Education – Engineering and Research Oriented. Universities to take a relook at their programmes.
  • Training – Entrepreneurship, Vocational and business practices
  • Above all, nurture a culture of innovation.

Unless these and many more necessary steps are taken by the governments of those countries that have seen deindustrialization no significant job and wealth creation is possible slogans and statements of intent notwithstanding.

Even after that it will be a long haul.

 ---ooo---

Addendum:

Americans (USA) bought 16 million cars, SUVs and light trucks in 2024. Out of this 8 million were imports. Even in the cars made in USA only 40-50% was local content. Hence, local content in US car market is only 25%.

The US’ share in global R&D in automotive sector is a mere 18%.